Horror has a large catalog of films that did not get the cultural moment they deserved. This page narrows to horror entries with above-average ratings relative to their footprint.
Overlooked horror films that landed higher than their reputation — strong ratings, quiet fanbase.
Explore English movies in the RandomFlix catalog and keep drilling down into full title pages.
They Will Kill You
2026
Stronger ratings and healthier vote counts make these titles a better place to start if you want proof before you roll.
Succubus
2024
Psycho
1960
La Leyenda de los Chaneques
2023
Las leyendas: El origen
2021
Michael Jackson's Thriller
2008
The Shining
1980
Alien
1979
The Thing
1982
Abraham Lincoln Vampire Hunter: The Great Calamity
2012
The Legend of the Black Charro
2018
Ghosts
1997
The Legend of the Guanajuato Mummies
2014
These newer releases still fit the same lane, giving visitors more ways to branch deeper into the catalog.
Underrated Horror Movies is a curated discovery page on RandomFlix. It narrows the catalog with a hand-picked filter so rolling the dice inside this collection gives you relevant picks every time.
Each curated page applies a small set of filters (genre, decade, language, certification, or keyword) to the full RandomFlix catalog. Only titles that meet the public quality bar — poster, overview, released status, and at least ten votes — are eligible.
Yes. Open the Filters panel on this page to stack additional constraints (runtime, cast, director, rating) on top of the curated filter. Random picks always respect every active filter.
